Defined Benefit
Defined Contribution
Nonprofit

Survey: ESG Incorporation Nearly Doubles in 5 Years; Those Considering It Jumps

Survey: ESG Incorporation Nearly Doubles in 5 Years; Those Considering It Jumps
clock
2 min 36 sec

Each year, Callan surveys institutional investors to better understand their views on environmental, social, and governance principles, and the trends driving ESG adoption. In our recently published 2020 ESG Survey, we found that 42% of respondents incorporated ESG into their investment decision-making process, in line with the previous year’s level. But that figure has nearly doubled from the 22% of investors that incorporated ESG in 2013.

As significantly, we found that 33% of respondents not yet incorporating ESG were considering doing so, the highest in the survey’s history and nearly triple the level in 2019. This brings the ratio of those either incorporating or thinking about incorporating ESG to 61% of the total respondent pool in 2020.

Share of Respondents Considering ESG Incorporation
  • This year’s ESG Survey, conducted in mid-2020, reflects input from 102 U.S. institutional investors. For this survey, ESG factors include socially responsible investing (SRI, including divestment), sustainable investing, impact investing, and other associated terms. Respondents include public and corporate DB and DC plans, as well as endowments and foundations, ranging in assets under management from small (under $500 million) to large (more than $20 billion). The largest share of respondents (41%) is from the government sector.

Survey highlights:

  • Investor type: Public plans (36%) have incorporated ESG factors into the investment decision-making process at a slightly higher rate than their corporate counterparts (32%), but this level of incorporation was still dwarfed by that of endowments (63%) and foundations (57%).
  • Investor location: ESG adoption was highest by plans in the Northeast and on the West Coast.
  • Those not incorporating it: Despite the trends toward adoption, 56% of respondents did not incorporate ESG into investment decision-making—although as noted earlier, a third of those are considering it.
  • Motivations: The most frequently cited reason for incorporating ESG among respondents was to address stakeholder concerns. Conversely, the most frequently cited reason for not incorporating ESG was because the benefits of ESG incorporation were unproven or unclear. When comparing early adopters’ motivations for incorporating ESG versus recent adopters, recent adopters were more likely to be addressing stakeholder concerns and to be focused on an improved risk profile, while early adopters were focused on alignment with their organization’s values and impact.
Reasons-for-ESG-Incorporation-by-Investor-Type-768x696
* Multiple responses allowed
  • Allocations: Only 19% of respondents maintain an ESG allocation separate from their traditional portfolio, indicating broader ESG integration is preferred.
  • Implementation: Over half of respondents that incorporate ESG have communicated ESG’s importance to their investment managers, consider ESG with every investment/investment manager selection, and added ESG language to their IPS.
  • Coronavirus impact: 60% of respondents said the global COVID-19 pandemic has had no impact on their planned ESG initiatives, while 14% believed the pandemic will cause them to increase their rate of ESG adoption.
  • Product interest: Active U.S. equity (33%) led the list of strategies those implementing ESG would like to see more of, followed by active emerging market equity (28%).
  • Future direction: 37% of respondents that have incorporated ESG factors in investment decision-making do not plan to make any changes to their usage of ESG factors in the coming years.

This blog post provides a high-level overview of our survey findings. For the entire survey, with detailed data and analysis, please click below.

Share
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Related Posts
Defined Benefit

What You Need to Know About Green Building Certifications

Aaron Quach
Green building certifications vary significantly based on their objective, administrator, and prominence in the industry.
Defined Contribution

Will Boring Still Be Beautiful?

James Veneruso
A simple, "boring," glidepath beat a diversified one over the last 10 years. Will that continue?
Defined Benefit

The Kids Are Alright

Gary Robertson
Private equity is doing quite well given the disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.
Defined Benefit

Stimulus Hopes Boosted Risky Bets

Jim McKee
The impact of hope upon markets was spread unequally, but active bets of hedge funds proved mostly positive.
Defined Benefit

DOL Issues Final Rule on Selecting Plan Investments

Thomas Shingler
In the final rule, the DOL modified the ESG rule, most notably removing references to ESG.
Defined Benefit

The Private Equity Playbook: Playing Offense

Private Equity Consulting
Investors should maintain strong oversight of the in-place private equity program, particularly after periods of disruption
Defined Contribution

IRS Announces Updated Retirement Plan Limits for 2021

Jamie McAllister
The IRS announced the updated retirement plan limits for 2021.
Defined Benefit

Skin in the Game: How New Risk-Retention Rules Affect the CMBS Market

Barbara Bernard
Prior to the Global Financial Crisis, issuers of commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) passed 100% of the risk to bondholders. After the GFC, t...
Defined Benefit

Updated COVID-19 Survey: Most Managers’ Offices Closed, With Many Not Reopening Until 2021

Shane Blanton
Overall, managers were much less optimistic about the resumption of business as usual in September compared to our first survey in June.
Defined Contribution

DOL Proposes Tightened Proxy Voting Guidelines

Patrick Wisdom
The department’s new proposal dovetails with SEC guidance finalized in 2020 and would create a refined set of circumstances in which plan fiduciarie...