Defined Contribution

Will Boring Still Be Beautiful?

Will Boring Still Be Beautiful?
1 min 36 sec

“Reports of my death have been greatly exaggerated.”

—Mark Twain

In setting the rules governing qualified default investment alternatives (QDIAs), the Department of Labor (DOL) mandated that a default option must contain a mix of “equity and fixed income exposures.” As a result, many target date funds (the most prevalent QDIA) have glidepaths with a diversified mix of asset classes. But judging by the past decade or so, diversification has proven a headwind for TDFs.

Instead, boring has been beautiful. To illustrate this, Callan constructed a hypothetical “most boring glidepath” containing only the S&P 500 and Bloomberg Barclays US Aggregate Bond Indices to meet the minimum diversification standard for a QDIA.

The result: Our boring glidepath performs better historically compared to peers, as well as to a glidepath containing the market average underlying exposure to 24 distinct asset classes. Below we show results for an age 45 allocation using both our boring glidepath and the 24 asset class glidepath. We imposed the index returns for these asset classes upon the glidepath, going back 10 years.

Boring vs. Diversified Glidepath for 10 Years Ending 6/30/20

Keep in mind that going “boring” would have resulted in lower fees, superior performance, and the perception of lower fiduciary risk. Over a 10-year period, contributions would have grown 17% more with the boring glidepath. This incorporates only asset allocation, not the impact (or lack) of alpha and the effect of fees.

Does this analysis point to an existential crisis for diversification, or at least a sad revisiting of investing orthodoxy? No. Buried in the small print is the usual caveat: “Past performance is not indicative of future results.” Perhaps we can take solace in the belief that the next 10 years will be unlike the past decade (that’s my belief!). But our analysis does help explain why few plans have embraced alternatives and other sources of non-correlated returns, and that their day may come in the future.

Posted by

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Related Posts
Defined Contribution

DOL Shifts Tone on Private Equity in DC Plans

Patrick Wisdom
Patrick Wisdom analyzes the new DOL guidance on the role of private equity in DC plans.
Defined Benefit

Can U.S. Equities Outrun Inflation?

Adam Lozinski
Adam Lozinski and Gordon Weightman analyze the long-term performance of U.S. equities compared to inflation.
Defined Benefit

Exclusive Callan Study Analyzes Investment Management Fees Paid by Institutional Investors

Ivan "Butch" Cliff
Butch Cliff provides the latest update for our proprietary investment management fee study.
Defined Benefit

U.S. Stocks Thrive While Global ex-U.S. Shares Lag; U.S. Fixed Income Flat

Kristin Bradbury
Kristin Bradbury analyzes 4Q21 performance for U.S. and global equities and fixed income.
Defined Benefit

Cautiously Optimistic Forecast on the Economy, Tempered by Clouds

Kristin Bradbury
Kristin Bradbury analyzes the U.S. economy in 4Q21 and the macroeconomic outlook for 2022.
Defined Benefit

Do Fiscal Policies Influence Investment Returns?

Paul Erlendson
Paul Erlendson examines whether fiscal policy and tax rates affect investment returns.
Defined Benefit

How Investors Should Respond to Evergrande and China’s Regulatory Crackdown

Fanglue Zhou
Fanglue Zhou analyzes how China's recent challenges impact institutional investors' emerging market allocations.
Defined Benefit

Is 2% Growth Good or Bad?

Jay Kloepfer
Jay Kloepfer examines GDP growth in 3Q21 and its implications for the future course of the recovery.
Defined Contribution

IRS Announces Updated Retirement Plan Limits for 2022

Jamie McAllister
Jamie McAllister details the new retirement plan limits for 2022.
Defined Benefit

Callan Survey Finds Nearly 50% of Respondents Incorporate ESG, Highest Level Ever

Thomas Shingler
Tom Shingler provides key takeaways from the Callan 2021 ESG Survey.