Defined Contribution

Breaking the Ice on Retirement Income Solutions—A Conversation Starter

Breaking the Ice on Retirement Income Solutions—A Conversation Starter
clock
3 min 47 sec

Retirement income solutions (RIS) have increasingly become a topic of conversation for defined contribution (DC) plan sponsors, mainly driven by these trends:

  • The 2019 SECURE Act, which helped clear the way for annuities in DC plans
  • A gradual shift in focus to the distribution phase of retirement
  • Longer life expectancy and increased concerns around longevity risk
  • An increase in plans seeking to retain retiree assets (83% of plans, according to Callan’s 2021 Defined Contribution Survey)
  • The shift away from traditional defined benefit (DB) plans as the primary source for funding retirement

Some sponsors have already implemented bespoke solutions in their plans; however, the overwhelming majority have either not explored or are only beginning to explore the full opportunity set of potential solutions. There are two major categories of income solutions: non-guaranteed and guaranteed. 

On the non-guaranteed side, many plans already have some of these solutions available to participants:

  • Stable value funds
  • Managed accounts (45% of plans, according to the DC Survey)
  • “Retirement” vintages of a target date fund (TDF) series

Additionally, managed payout funds are a developing area in the non-guaranteed category. These have a targeted payout percentage, and a participant can have an expected dollar income amount based on the amount invested.

Prevalence on the guaranteed side is much lower, as these are newer offerings available to DC plans, mainly in the form of annuities (12% of plans offered some form of annuities, according to the DC Survey):

  • Immediate annuities: allow a participant to purchase a stream of income at a single point in time
  • Qualified longevity annuity contracts (QLACs): a deferred annuity typically purchased around retirement age (e.g., 65) where payments begin between ages 80 to 85 (6% of plans, according to the DC Survey)
  • Unassigned deferred annuity products: a pooled annuity product that balances maintaining a level of liquidity with the potential to receive a stream of income. These can be thought of as call options on purchasing an annuity.
  • Guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit (GMWB): similar to a managed payout fund, but the payout rate is guaranteed based on locking in an underlying portfolio value (5% of plans, according to the DC Survey)

There are many factors to consider when discussing if a retirement income solution makes sense and, if so, which are the appropriate ones. Below are some key questions to help guide the discussion:

What is the plan sponsor’s retiree/terminated asset policy?

  • An RIS may make sense if terminated employee assets are retained and/or there is a large population of retirees.

What are the characteristics of the plan participants?

  • An RIS may make sense if participant turnover is low and the majority are in the plan for the bulk of their careers.

Are there other income sources in retirement?

  • An RIS may make sense if a participant does not have access to a DB plan and/or Social Security.

What is the fiduciary structure?

  • An RIS may make sense if fiduciary resources are robust (e.g., knowledgeable, long-tenured committee and staff, with time and resources).

What is the fiduciary risk?

  • If plans are willing to be “first movers,” an RIS may make sense.

Is there buy-in from all parties?

  • An RIS may make sense if there is administrative support from the recordkeeper and support from the consultant, insurers, the legal department, and managers.

Will participants use the solution?

  • If use is expected to be high, an RIS may make sense.

What is the existing investment structure of the plan?

  • If a custom approach is taken, an RIS may make sense.

Is there a reason to offer the solution in the plan?

  • An RIS may make sense if there are concrete benefits to offering the solution in the plan.

Is a custom or off-the-shelf solution the right choice?

How should a solution be implemented—as a standalone solution or as part of a TDF series?

Will plan documents need to be updated to allow for more distribution flexibility (installments, periodic distributions)?

What sort of distributional flexibility can the recordkeeper accommodate?

One additional area to consider for plan sponsors that offer a defined benefit plan is looking at historical behavior, specifically if participants have taken a lump sum or an annuity distribution. This data can serve as a live case study and, if most participants are choosing a lump sum from their pension, it may be difficult to justify that they would use an income solution in the DC plan.

Key Takeaway: While prevalence is low, DC plans are increasingly adding a discussion of retirement income solutions to their agendas. Decisions about a potential solution require a robust thought process, and the aim of this blog post is to serve as a starting point to explore which, if any, solution may be appropriate for a particular plan.

Posted by

Share
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Related Posts
Defined Benefit

When the Passive Index Is an Active Decision

Weston Lewis
Because of differences in passive indices, investors should understand how the one they choose will affect benchmarking.
Defined Benefit

Capital Markets Assumptions and the Future

Greg Allen
CEO and Chief Research Officer Greg Allen analyzes how Callan's capital markets assumptions have compared to actual returns.
Defined Benefit

SEC Division of Examinations Issues ESG Risk Alert

Thomas Shingler
The Division issued the Risk Alert to 1) communicate its observations from past examinations and 2) address the Division’s areas of focus during upc...
Defined Benefit

Equities Off to a Strong Start; Inflation Fears Haunt Bonds

Kristin Bradbury
U.S. equities outpaced global stocks in 1Q21. The 10-year U.S. Treasury yield hit its highest intraday yield in 15 months during the quarter.
Defined Benefit

2021—Starting Off with Gusto!

Kristin Bradbury
How the economy did in 1Q21, and the outlook ahead.
Defined Benefit

What We Found in Our Latest COVID-19 Survey of Investment Managers

Amy Jones
The 3rd edition of our Coping with COVID-19 survey of investment managers focuses on plans for office reopenings and vaccination policies.
Defined Benefit

The Story Behind Callan’s 2021 Capital Markets Assumptions

Capital Markets Research
An explanation of Callan's 2021-2030 Capital Markets Assumptions, how they were developed, and what changed from last year's projections.
Defined Benefit

Bloomberg Barclays Pricing Time Change and What It Means for Institutional Investors

Kyle Fekete
Asset owners, investment managers, and other parties may experience discrepancies in reporting point-in-time pricing or performance as a result.
Defined Benefit

Why the Yield Curve Is Really Curving

Dario Buechi
As prospects for growth have brightened, yields on longer maturity bonds have risen while short-term rates have been anchored by the Fed.
Defined Contribution

DOL Announces It Won't Enforce ESG, Proxy-Voting Rules

Thomas Shingler
Both of the rules were published in the final months of the Trump administration.