Capital Markets

Follow the Money: Asset Flow Data Support Industry Trends

Follow the Money: Asset Flow Data Support Industry Trends
clock
4 min 20 sec

Twice a year, Callan takes a deep dive into asset flow data to extrapolate trends and identify the most successful investment managers in each asset class. What we found in our most recent analysis, for year-end 2017, is consistent with many of the broad challenges the institutional asset management industry is facing. However, this analysis did uncover some areas of opportunity for investment managers. Data described in this post are derived from Callan’s Style, Trend, Analysis, and Research (STAR) Report, a paid service offered by Callan’s Institutional Consulting Group. Accordingly, we must refrain from sharing the full data set, but are excited to describe some of the main themes that emerged from the analysis.

Callan’s STAR report separates assets into three buckets: U.S. tax-exempt separate account and commingled fund assets, institutional share classes of mutual funds, and retail share classes of mutual funds. Throughout this blog post, we will focus only on U.S. tax-exempt assets.

Active vs. Passive

Any conversation on key trends in the investment industry would be incomplete without addressing the shift to passive management. However, measuring the success of passive management versus active management cannot be done by looking at the absolute level of inflows and outflows. Shifts in asset allocation and rebalancing efforts can create active management outflows, but they will also cause passive outflows. Therefore, it is better to look at the difference between active outflows and passive outflows. This is a reasonable estimate of the size of the flow to passive assets from active. Data in Exhibit 1 show that an average of $48 billion in U.S. tax-exempt separate account and commingled fund assets have flowed into passive large cap from active large cap annually since 2012.

Exhibit 1: U.S. Tax-Exempt Passive Large Cap Flows less Active Large Cap Flows

However, as any asset manager is likely to tell you, this phenomenon is not limited to large cap. Since 2012, an average of $20 billion and $27 billion has moved from active to passive for U.S. small cap and non-U.S. equity, respectively.

The Natural Limits of Diversification

As Einstein famously postulated in 1905, even the speed of light has a limit. So it should follow that portfolio diversification also has a limit, and we are beginning to see that play out in asset flow data. In 2016, Jay Kloepfer and Julia Moriarty of Callan’s Capital Markets Research group co-authored a paper titled Risky Business, in which they looked at how portfolios have needed to become more complex over time in order to reach a 7.5% return (Exhibit 2).

Exhibit 2: Shift in Allocations to Reach a 7.5% return

Yet, these increased allocations to asset classes such as non-U.S. equity, real estate, and private equity must come at the expense of other asset classes. One funding source for these increased allocations has been core and core plus fixed income. Callan’s STAR data shows that the degree to which these asset classes have been used as a funding source appears to be decreasing. As shown in Exhibit 3, these asset flows have slowly become less negative over the past decade and actually turned positive in 2017.

Exhibit 3: Core and Core Plus Fixed Income Net Flows

Callan did not see a lot of new assets being allocated to core and core plus during 2017, suggesting that money may have come into the asset classes due to rebalancing and that the natural limits of diversification have begun to stem the outflows from core and core plus.

Where Is the Money Going?

The STAR analysis tracks asset data at the investment strategy level. Therefore, when assets leave, we cannot see exactly where they go, but that does not prevent us from being able to make inferences. An understanding of industry trends is particularly useful in this exercise. For example, Callan works with many plan sponsors that have shifted their policy benchmark to the MSCI ACWI ex-USA IMI Index. A move from an EAFE index to an ACWI index will include the addition of emerging markets. Similarly, shifting from ACWI to ACWI IMI expands the universe to include non-U.S. small cap. Therefore, it stands to reason that both the emerging market equity and non-U.S. small cap asset classes would have experienced inflows over the past several years, and that is exactly what the data in Exhibit 4 shows.

Exhibit 4: Emerging Markets and Non-U.S. SC Net Flows

Last year’s Callan data show outflows of U.S. tax-exempt assets from emerging market equity. However, it is helpful to keep in mind that this was a year during which the MSCI Emerging Markets Index returned 37.8%, likely causing rebalancing activity away from the asset class.

Why Is This important?

Asset flow data can be a valuable tool used to identify, validate, or question trends in the investment industry. Increasingly, investment managers are making important decisions about their future business strategies and fund sponsors are seeking to understand what their peers are doing in the face of low capital market return expectations. It is important to make sure these decisions are based upon a combination of quality data and a deep understanding of the qualitative factors shaping the investment landscape.

Callan’s proprietary STAR Report goes into extensive detail about all of these asset classes. If you are interested in more information, please feel free to contact Joan Dorow with Callan’s Institutional Consulting Group at [email protected].

Callan College banner

Posted by

Share
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Related Posts
ESG

The Heat Is On! Carbon-Footprinting Basics for Institutional Investors

Amit Bansal
Amit Bansal explains what carbon-footprinting means for institutional investors.
ESG

Callan Study Examines ESG Practices by Investment Managers

Kristin Bradbury
Kristin Bradbury summarizes our 2023 Asset Manager ESG Study.
Operations

Unlocking the Secrets of the 'Data Vault'

Bo Abesamis
Bo Abesamis describes the Callan "Data Vault," a repository where data is collected, cleansed, aggregated, and curated.
ESG

Green Financing in Residential Real Estate

Aaron Quach
Christine Mays and Aaron Quach explain green financing and how it can help investment managers obtain more favorable financing terms.
Private Markets

Alignment of Interests: Best Practices to Make Sure Investors and Their Managers Are in Sync

Jan Mende
Jan Mende discusses how institutional investors can make sure their interests are aligned with their private markets investment managers.
Operations

Capital Markets Assumptions and the Future

Greg Allen
CEO and Chief Research Officer Greg Allen and Senior Vice President Julia Moriarty analyze how Callan's capital markets assumptions have compared to a...
Public Markets

Why It Was a Tough 4Q21 for Large Cap Growth Managers

David Wang
David Wang analyzes the tough market environment for large cap growth investment managers in 4Q21.
Operations

Three Potential Paths to a China A-Shares Allocation

Global Manager Research
We discuss three paths to implementing a China A-shares allocation.
Operations

The Technology Revolution Catches Up to Commercial Real Estate

Bernie Bazile
Bernie Bazile explains "proptech" and what institutional investors need to know about it.
Operations

What We Found in Our Latest COVID-19 Survey of Investment Managers

Global Manager Research
The 3rd edition of our Coping with COVID-19 survey of investment managers focuses on plans for office reopenings and vaccination policies.

Callan Family Office

You are now leaving Callan LLC’s website and going to Callan Family Office’s website. Callan Family Office is not affiliated with Callan LLC.  Callan LLC has licensed the Callan® trademark to Callan Family Office for use in providing investment advisory services to ultra-high net worth clients, family foundations, and endowments. Callan Family Office and Callan LLC are independent, unaffiliated investment advisory firms separately registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940.

Callan LLC is not responsible for the services and content on Callan Family Office’s website. Inclusion of this link does not constitute or imply an endorsement, sponsorship, or recommendation by Callan LLC of their website, or its contents, and Callan LLC is not responsible or liable for your use of it. When visiting their website, you are subject to Callan Family Office’s terms of use and privacy policies.